- Book information
- Beyond the God Particle by Leon Lederman and Christopher Hill
- Published by: Prometheus
- Price: $24.95
After all the excitement surrounding the discovery of the Higgs, a new book called Beyond the God Particle asks where we go next
IN 2012 American Independence Day was a high-water mark for European science: it saw the announcement of the discovery of the Higgs boson at the Large Hadron Collider, near Geneva, Switzerland.
In Beyond the God Particle, co-written with fellow particle physicist Christopher Hill, Lederman bemoans the short-sightedness of American politicians who pulled the plug on the Superconducting Supercollider (SSC) in 1993 and signalled the retreat of the US from the high-energy frontier of fundamental physics.
But while the US Congress may well have lacked what Lederman and Hill call "leadership cojones", it is perhaps unfair to blame Congress entirely. The plan for the SSC was to excavate a vast circular tunnel in Waxahachie, Texas, while the LHC plan proposed reusing an existing subterranean ring. Confining a superfast beam to such a small particle racetrack could be achieved only with superconducting magnets of such power that they were pure science fiction at the time the LHC was proposed.
In short, European scientists displayed the kind of daring, can-do spirit formerly seen in American scientists of the Apollo moon-shot era. As a consequence, and ironically, they presented their collective funding governments with a far lower total bill for the enterprise.
Although Lederman and Hill mourn the SSC, they seem to have accepted that European-style international collaborations with their pooled financial resources are the sensible way forward for particle physics.
Even so, they want to see the US punching its weight in particle physics again. In 2015, the LHC will start operating at even higher energies. Lederman and Hill suggest an American "Project X" to coincide with this, to look for ultra-rare, low-energy processes that may reveal a new fundamental physics.
It's a bold plan, and well argued, but the real meat of Beyond the God Particle is the Higgs boson itself and its raison d'être. And this is a truly fascinating story, well told.
Mass, in a nutshell, is not what you think it is. Not by a long chalk.According to Lederman and Hill, a subatomic particle such as a muon, which feels the weak nuclear force, flickers back and forth between a right and a left corkscrewing form (the flicker is known as Zitterbewegung).
If, however, the muon could be boosted to the speed of light, its time would slow to a standstill, as predicted by Einstein's special theory of relativity. A particle that experiences no passage of time is a photon, so the muon would appear like a photon. Since a photon has no rest mass, running with the photon analogy, neither would the superfast muon. Its mass would have been "switched off". But all that has happened to it is that the flickering between left and right forms has stopped. The inference is that this oscillation is what gives a muon its mass.
So where does the Higgs come in? In switching from the left to the right form, a muon must destroy its "weak charge", which is as impossible as destroying the ordinary electric charge. Hence the left-right switch must be mediated by another particle that takes away the weak charge.
The particle is not obvious so it must be short-lived, which in quantum theory is synonymous with being massive. It cannot add electric charge, so it must have zero electric charge. And it cannot add quantum "spin", so it must have zero spin, making it a boson. Hey presto, the recipe for the Higgs.
According to Lederman and Hill, the defining characteristic of bosons is their gregariousness. Just like the photons that make up an electromagnetic field, the bosons of the Higgs field like to be with their mates, crowding the vacuum that fills the universe. And it is the drag exerted on a muon as it continually has to interact with Higgs bosons in the vacuum that endows it with mass.
But while photons are easy to pluck from the electromagnetic field, Higgs bosons are immensely hard to pull from their field. In fact, that takes a whopping 125 gigaelectronvolts to be precise – which is why nothing less than the $9 billion LHC could do it.
All of this is about as far from the standard cocktail party description of how the Higgs generates mass as it is possible to get. And it is worth the price of the book alone. Mind you, three-quarters of the way through, Lederman and Hill do belatedly admit, with a sheepish apology, that the Higgs explains only a minuscule part of mass. The lion's share – 99 per cent – comes from the strong nuclear force and has nothing whatsoever to do with the weakly interacting Higgs. But then, this fact has been omitted by almost all particle physicists in their eagerness to big up the Higgs to the media.
- Subscribe to New Scientist and you'll get:
- New Scientist magazine delivered every week
- Unlimited access to all New Scientist online content -
a benefit only available to subscribers - Great savings from the normal price
- Subscribe now!
If you would like to reuse any content from New Scientist, either in print or online, please contact the syndication department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to.
Have your say
Only subscribers may leave comments on this article. Please log in.
Only personal subscribers may leave comments on this article
All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us.
If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.
